Does it matter if an interaction occurs face to face? Why? What suppositions do you bring to bear in thinking about this question?
The idea of whether face to face interaction really matters is a concern within our decade because the media has become so ingrained in our society. It really depends on the situation for whether or not it should be done in person.
When we walked into class and saw the screen and did not have a professor I was a caught off guard. Traditionally, we would walk into class on the first day and be given a syllabus and talk a little and then we would be dismissed. Today was not like that. This is one of those situations where a professor needs to be present. If we have to come to class so should a professor. They are there to teach us face-to-face so we can ask questions when we have them and we were full of them today. Asking a screen questions about the course does not give us any answers. Also having a teacher in class teaching allows for a student to ask for clarification or for a the teacher to go off on a tangent and interject with stories of personal knowledge that add and enhance the class. It also adds some structure and allows us to know what we are up against for the rest of the semester."It is in the repetitiveness of the everyday, its very familiarity and predictability, that such securities are sought and sometimes found."(Silverstone) http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/new_literary_history/v033/33.4silverstone.pdf I felt more anxiety not being able to ask questions and not having boundaries of what was going to happen in class. I like having the routine of seeing a professor everyday. Having the repetition of always having a professor leads to security that is important to me and not having that caught me off guard. I did not feel anymore freedom than I would have if a professor was there. I would have acted and done exactly what I always do with or without a professor.
There are few times where over the Internet is acceptable instead of a face-to-face interaction. "Chatting with hot babes all day" is acceptable but if a relationship were to develop meeting in person would be necessary for breaking apart any relationship despite where a person meets them. It is not classy at all in any situation to break up with someone over the internet or phone. Quick things that are straight forward do not warrant a face-to-face meeting. But there are somethings in which it is necessary for a meeting to occur.
A lot can be learned from looking at someone as they talk and the way they carry themselves. As Rushton states "the face provides an instrument panel upon which a scale of reflexes, emotions, and thoughts are registered." (5/19)http://muse.jhu.edu/journals/cultural_critique/v051/51.1rushton.pdf It is important and people can learn a lot from the face-to-face interaction. A person's emotions can be displayed clearly on their face but if they were just chatting with someone online then that other person may not be able to fully comprehend what is being said. The tone in which something is expressed is also important. Sarcasm is far better when being said aloud to a person that someone else trying to interpret it through text.
A job interview would also be something that would be face to face. An employer would need to look at how they interact with people, their body language, the way they talk and their outfit. A heavy accent may impede some one's ability to convey their message which could easily be hidden via the Internet. If they are not confident or have facial piercings or visible tattoos, these are things that would be visible in an interview. Some of these things could be found out through the Internet but the overall presence of someone would only be found out through personal interaction.
Therefore I think it is really important to have face-to-face interactions especially in certain circumstances. It is what has traditionally been done and worked for our society and should continue.
Tuesday, September 2, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
4 comments:
This is really interesting. You need, though, to copy this post onto the blog you are making for the class rather than have a separate blog for each assignment. Let me know when you do and I'll add the link for your blog to the class list.
Why do you think that the presence of a person provides structure that a screen of instructions does not? Is it primarily a matter of predictability (as your very good use of Silverstone suggests)? Is it because a text doesn't seem to answer? Why do you think that no one in the class thought of ya'll posting questions directly on/to the locationf8 blog?
I am going to wait to make a new blog since we decided to make a group one. I originally had one that was pol363 but apparently it didn't work. It took me a little while.
I think it adds structure because it is direct interaction and questions can be answered right away and we wouldn't have to wait for a response. I don't think anyone even considered putting anything on the locationf8 because none of us really had any experience with blogs. We took a poll and only 2 out of all of us had ever even used a blog. I had no clue how to use it. But I think we are getting a better understanding now and hopefully it will be easier. I think it will be better now that our group is going to make a group post. That way we can ask each other questions about the assignment and posting right away since we are meeting in the airport lounge tomorrow to discuss the readings and assignments.
Is there any way to save a blog and finish it later? I tried it saving it but it didn't work and it won't let me cut and paste so I don't know what else to do. I also don't know where to post this so everyone will see it.
Do you mean save a post? The answer is yes--you save it as a draft.
The blog is like a visible folder or collection of posts. There are also comments on the posts. So far all you have are comments in a folder but no posts.
The key here: you are learning by doing.
(This is from Professor Dean; I didn't realize that my son's account was the open one when I started writing my response.)
Post a Comment